The biggest Pinocchios of 2015

No Comment 1 View



It’s time for a annual round-up of a biggest Pinocchios of a year.

The 2016 presidential debate has dominated a coverage of fake claims. In particular, businessman Donald Trump — who has soared to a tip of a GOP margin — kept us busy. In a space of usually 6 months, he warranted 11 Four-Pinocchio ratings, distant some-more than any other candidate.

Most politicians dump a explain after it has been fact-checked as false. But Trump is surprising in that he always insists he is right, no matter how small justification he has for his claim. Frankly, it’s unequivocally not engaging to fact check The Donald, as his assertions are so simply debunked. Still, he scores a shawl pretence on this list.

We also clinging a series of columns this year to exploring a indeterminate statistics about sex trafficking of children in a United States. It’s a terrible crime, yet we are giving a special endowment for statistical hypocrisy to a many politicians and organizations who have shouted indeterminate contribution about it. To their credit, some have affianced to do better.

In compiling this list, that has no sold order, we essentially focused on claims that had warranted Four Pinocchios during a year. We also attempted to concentration on issues of extended interest. To keep it simple, we have condensed a quotes in a headlines. To review a full column, click on a couple embedded in a quote.

“I watched thousands and thousands of Muslims in New Jersey hearten as a World Trade Center fell.”

Donald Trump secretly and regularly asserted that he saw radio images of Muslims in New Jersey celebrating a fall of a twin towers after a 9/11 attacks. Despite steady debunking of this claim, Trump continued to explain he was correct, even yet he could furnish no justification solely a handful of news stories that done brief mentions of purported celebrations — that never could be confirmed.


“DOMA had to be enacted to stop an anti-gay matrimony amendment to a U.S. Constitution.”

(REUTERS/Mike Blake)

Former secretary of state Hillary Clinton, a Democratic front-runner, shielded her husband’s signing of a anti-gay Defense of Marriage Act as a defensive action, to forestall a inherent anathema on same-sex marriage. But there is small justification in a open record that was a case, even yet Clinton claimed “there was adequate domestic momentum” during a time to rectify a constitution. (Clinton after pronounced it only had come adult in “private discussions.”)




“The Mexican Government is forcing criminals, drug dealers and rapists into a United States.”

Donald Trump regularly shielded this claim, yet a range of studies uncover there is no justification immigrants dedicate some-more crimes than native-born Americans. Moreover, a immeasurable infancy of unapproved immigrants in jail do not belong in a difficulty that fits Trump’s description: aggravated felons, whose crimes embody murder, drug trafficking or bootleg trafficking of firearms.



“Since Sandy Hook there has been a propagandize shooting, on average, each week.”

(AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) done this explain in June, that indicated 128 propagandize shootings given Dec 2014. The series came from a anti-gun organisation Everytown for Gun Safety, yet a methodology was deeply flawed, including suicides, random discharges and so forth. Official supervision statistics are most lower, indicating a domestic hazard of relying on advocacy groups.


“Obama skeleton to acknowledge 250,000 Syrian refugees.”

(AP Photo/Julie Jacobson)

Donald Trump initial pronounced President Obama designed to acknowledge 200,000 Syrian refugees, a figure conjured out of skinny air. Then it became 250,000. But a genuine figure is 10,000. The United States is usually formulation to acknowledge 180,000 refugees from all countries in a subsequent dual years. Trump’s false rhetoric desirous other GOP possibilities to offer extravagantly arrogant total as well.




“With Al Gore, we helped classify a initial hearings in a Senate on meridian change in 1988.”

Secretary of State John F. Kerry for years has pronounced he orderly a initial Senate hearings on meridian change with then-Sens. Al Gore and Tim Wirth. But that was false. Kerry was not during a pivotal 1988 conference in a Senate — and conjunction was Gore, who orderly a initial conference in a House in 1981. On tip of that, Kerry described witnessing events that did not happen.



“The scholarship on meridian change is not staid since in 1970s we were disturbed about ‘global freezing.’”

(Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Former Arkansas administrator Mike Huckabee (R) cited a “covers” of Time and Newsweek to explain tellurian frozen had been a critical regard 40 years ago. But these were not cover stories, usually removed examples of suppositional journalism. It was never a critical concern; researchers found that peer-reviewed articles on tellurian cooling were in a graphic minority compared to those endangered with tellurian warming.



“Auto play markups cost consumers $26 billion a year.”

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), pulling for new regulations of loans done by automobile dealers, cited a figure formed on a indeterminate and antiquated news from a Center for Responsible Lending, an advocacy group. But afterwards she also extravagantly mischaracterized a number, as even a advocacy organisation conceded that a figure includes reasonable remuneration due to automobile dealers.



“Obama never says a United States is well-developed or great.”

(Brendan Smialowski/Getty Images)

Former New York City mayor Rudolph Giuliani (R) asserted that Obama, distinct other Democratic presidents such as Bill Clinton, Jimmy Carter or Harry Truman, never pronounced a United States was a good or well-developed country. This was a weird claim. We resolved Giuliani contingency have pale a sound whenever Obama spoke, since there are many examples of Obama observant accurately that.



“The Keystone tube is for oil that bypasses a United States.”

(Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg)

Long before President Obama killed a Keystone tube project, he done a series of indeterminate claims about it, including that a tube would have no advantage for American producers during all. But a wanton oil would have trafficked to a Gulf Coast, where it would be polished into products such as engine gasoline and diesel fuel; a State Department pronounced contingency were low that all would be exported. Also, about 12 percent of a pipeline’s ability had been set aside for wanton from North Dakota and Montana.


“A male was put in jail for swindling usually for carrying mud on his land.”

(AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)

Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) desired to tell a story of an aged male sitting in jail for 10 years after being indicted of racketeering and orderly crime — usually for putting mud on his land. But usually about each aspect of Paul’s recounting was fake and misleading. The man, Robert Lucas, was convicted of mail fraud, swindling and environmental violations for his purpose in building 67 mobile home lots inside federally stable wetlands, building on wetlands but capitulation and intentionally offered land with bootleg sewage systems that were expected to fail.


“Hands up, don’t shoot.”

(REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton)

This word became a rallying cry for protests after a deadly sharpened of a black 18-year-old by a white military officer, Darren Wilson. Witness accounts widespread after a sharpened that Michael Brown had his hands lifted in surrender, mouthing a difference “Don’t shoot” as his final difference before being shot execution-style. Democratic lawmakers lifted their hands in oneness on a House floor. But several investigations resolved this did not occur — and that Wilson acted out of self-defense and was fit in murdering Brown.



Special award: Bushels of fraudulent sex trafficking statistics

(iStock by Getty Images)

No singular emanate warranted some-more Pinocchios than indeterminate claims about sex trafficking. There are not 300,000 children during risk for passionate exploitation. There are not 100,000 children in a sex trade. Human trafficking is not a $9.5 billion business in a United States. Girls do not turn victims of sex trafficking during an normal age of 13 years. The sovereign supervision has not arrested hundreds of sex traffickers. These were all fake claims done in 2015 by politicians, advocacy groups and supervision officials.




(About a rating scale)


Send us contribution to check by stuffing out this form

Check out a 2016 possibilities fact-check page

Sign adult for The Fact Checker weekly newsletter

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked (required)


Mojo Marketplace

Newark - Simple & Minimal WordPress Blog

Lifestyle Elegant & Simple WordPress Blog Theme

Beyond Creative Multi-Purpose WordPress Theme